Someone I am is waiting for my courage (forgotten_aria) wrote,
Someone I am is waiting for my courage
forgotten_aria

antidotal evidence

I was watching a program which was (badly) debating if you could be healthy and over weight. One side included someone who had been a model and had nearly killed her self with her skinnyness, but was now a "plus sized" model at size 12. The other side had someone who had been horribly unhealthy while overweight and had lost her weight and regained her health.

What the once fat person couldn't see if that to prove that not all skinny people are healthy, the single example of the model being unhealthy proves that but to prove that all fat people are unhealthy, you can not just say, "I was unhealthy" and have it even chip away at the burden of evidence.

I wonder if this is a fundemental problem that some people have understanding the world?

Also, why didn't anyone point out that the "plus size" model wasn't overweight at all? This doesn't actual add to the arguement, other than the definition of "fat" needs some work.

Sadly the show was completely dumb.
Tags: arguement, fat
Subscribe

  • Yes! Things are what I like to do!

    I feel I should post an update, because it's been a while an many things have been happening. My mother finally went home after her…

  • overweight != unhealthy

    In general, I like the Simpsons. Sometimes the episode isn't that funny, but in general there's usually a good laugh or two. The episode "Walking…

  • Running

    I'm tired of being fat (though this is nothing new.) I realize this is a poor motivation for exercise since weight loss is a lost cause but good…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

  • 6 comments